Is The Big HandiHoldall Car Roof Bag A Good Choice For Large Families?
Instead of the standard-sized black box or soft-shelled container, there is a massive blue bag that takes up most of the available space.
It looks enormous and ideal for large families, but is there the risk of it being too much to handle?
The Pros and Cons of this HandiHoldall Car Roof Bag.
- The capacity of this roof bag is enormous
- The soft material also means that the storage space is more adaptable
- That material is strong and PVC coated for added protection
- There are lots of straps to loop around the roof rack to hold it in place
- After use, it folds down small into a complimentary storage bag
- There are still occasional issues of rain getting in
- You need to load the bag and lock it up before securing it to the top of the car
- The heavy weight and lack of aerodynamics could have an impact on your journey
The HandiHoldall Car Roof Bag is massive and should be a spacious and secure way to load up your car.
One of the main reasons for choosing a roof bag over a roof box is that you can play around with the space a little more. Putting luggage in a rigid hard-cased box can be tricky, especially when there is an aerodynamic tapered design to work around.
Here, the softer fabric and the large 330 litre volume mean that it should be a lot easier to put everything need in one adaptable container.
There is also the fact that the soft material folds down with ease for storage when not in use. There is actually a case included in this package for that purpose.
The roof bag looks like it should be nice and secure as there are plenty of straps with buckles all around the structure. All you need to do is loop the straps around a roof rack and tighten them as needed.
There is also a secure zipper running around the bag with a lock. Just be aware that this method means that you can’t secure the bag and then fill it up, which can be an issue on windier days. It has to be full and locked before fitting the straps.
Some concerns about the size and the weatherproofing could hold the HandiHoldall Car Bag back.
This bag is made to be weather-resistant, with tough 600D polyester laminated with PVC. There are also taped seams to keep the water out.
However, there are reports of water getting in around some of the holes in the stitching, while there is also an issue with the size and position of the velcro storm flap.
There are also concerns about the stitching on the straps. Some users have no problem at all and find the bag to be very secure. Others experienced breakages. Perhaps it all depends on the weight added to the bag and the amount of strain.
Of course, there is a downside in choosing something so large and rectangular for the top of your car. Tapered boxes may be less spacious, but they don’t have as many issues with drag as the car travels.
This boxier shape means a big flat surface at the front of the car that could inhibit speed and performance.
There is also the risk that the large capacity will end up with a lot of extra weight on the car, which could be a problem for the tyres and general roadworthiness of your vehicle.
How does this all affect a final verdict on this HandiHoldall Large Blue Roof Bag?
It is easy to get weighed down by the disadvantages here – pun intended. This massive bag could be a burden in some ways and a pain to set up at first.
Yet, there is no doubt that families will be able to throw a lot into the structure and make use of the storage bag.
The concerns about the weatherproofing aren’t too much of a cause for concern unless you travel in really bad weather. As long as you are careful in your planning and don’t put too much strain on the straps, the HandiHoldall roof box could turn out to be a great choice.